Skip to main content

Modern times, medieval mindsets


Sometimes I feel like the 2020s are a lot like the 1020s must have been in medieval Europe. Now hear me out! I know we have a lot of technology and progress and modern day luxuries. But I feel like our mentalities, and a lot of our social and economic structures, are stuck back a thousand years ago.

The wealthiest live in castles on hilltops, beautiful manors with gardens and plenty to eat, not a care in the world. In the golden city - the desired place - the castles, the gardens, the fountains - are surrounded by dangers and treachery. Moats made up of snaking highways encircle the forbidden city, impossible to cross on foot. The wealthier ones have steeds they can mount to cross over into the golden city. Horses in the 1020s ... cars in the 2020s ....

There are bridge trolls at the off ramps into the golden city, demanding payment or exacting revenge. Panhandlers? Or criminals, waiting to pop tires and steal the precious jewels of a catalytic converter from underneath the steed ....

Small towns are like medieval fiefdoms. Each one is run by a boss - who has his own manor on the hill - running whatever the enterprise is in the town. Used to be factories, now pharmaceuticals, prisons, agribusiness. The peasants all have to suck up to their local boss if they want to be able to keep their small plots of land. And they are caught in a cycle of poverty and ignorance - holding onto ancient ideas that still hold sway despite their glaring hypocrisies. Glassy eyed, they bow down to their local warlord, paying homage, offering up daughters to be lifted up out of poverty by his benevolence (so they think), offering up sons to go invade Arab countries and bring back the spoils of their Holy Crusades.

The 'unholy' are banished away from the small-town fiefdoms into the cities. People with poxes, with blemishes on their body or soul - people who refuse to bow down to the local warlord, or those with gender dysphoria, those whose desires and love transcend the narrow-mindedness of small-town America, the broken men who return from their Crusades with afflictions of the body and mind -- they are banished from their fiefdoms and their clans. Sent to the edges of the golden cities, broken-down, hurting, in pain. There, they are kicked around and beaten down by the kings of the golden city. Forced to live as beggars, wearing rags and no shoes on their feet.

If they manage to make it past the bridge trolls of the golden city, they'll find the gleaming neighborhoods of the royals hidden deep within. Places like Alameda, the West Hills, Westmoreland -- in these green-tree-lined neighborhoods, the royal children ride bicycles along flowery, manicured streets. These children soon become teens whose posts on Instagram of their joyous, carefree lives are the modern equivalent of the displays of wealth made at medieval royal balls, that Tinder app of the eleventh century European elite.

But on the other side of the moat is a morass of human misery - people huddled in makeshift tents, or some with no covering at all, shivering in the cold and mostly ignored by the elite, who toss them a coin now and then to assuage their feelings of guilt. Some of these peasants were former royalty - kicked out and kicked down the ladder for challenging or resisting the top-down beat-down culture. But some come from generations of poverty - hunger beating them down, from mother to child to grandchild, until they are too weak to fight back.

Women who wanted to end an unwanted pregnancy in the 1020s would know which wise woman healer to seek out, and that healer would give her an herbal concoction to bring on the miscarriage. But if caught, this medieval abortion doctor would be tortured or killed as a witch. Are we really so far from that now? Abortion doctors are targets of assassinations, and in some states can be imprisoned in a gulag if they help a woman preserve her own bodily integrity by helping her end a pregnancy through abortion. And women can be forced to carry a pregnancy to term - her body is not her own, but the property of the state/fiefdom where she lives. 

There are many more parallels, I'm sure. But these are the ones in the forefront of my mind as I navigate our modern/medieval cities, towns and fiefdoms and encounter all around me attitudes and mindsets and habits that have stuck around for a thousand years, decaying the bodies and poisoning the minds of the people who perpetuate them year after year, generation after generation. If we look outside these cycles of violent, forced poverty and wealth, we can see that there are other ways to live. I think it's about time we get out of the 1020s, and look outside of medieval Europe for instructions on how to live together in a society.

Popular posts from this blog

100 Days of Genocide

100 days. and I feel numb. It started, this time, with something unusual. Something unheard of. We have become used, over the past 24 years of intifada suppression, to the regular bombings of Gaza. We heard the Israeli minister say in 2006 "We have decided to put the Palestinians on a diet", carefully calculating the number of trucks allowed to enter the tiny coastal enclave based on the Israeli calculation of the population of Gaza (a perpetual underestimate) and the Israeli calculation of the caloric intake that each Gazan should be allowed. And yet, the Gaza Strip flourished. Despite Israel's imprisonment of its population, guard towers looming large all along the north and east, and fishermen not allowed to go past the 3-mile Israeli-imposed nautical 'border'. Cut off from the world. Cut off from relatives in Haifa, Nazareth, Isdud, Lod. Cut off from family in Bethlehem, Jerusalem, Nablus, Jenin, al-Khalil. The lucky few who have escaped Gaza in the past eight...

Six People Have Been Killed while protesting George Floyd's murder -- Why is this not national news?

When the National Guard opened fire at a protest against the Vietnam War at Kent State University in 1970, killing four protesters, it was national news for weeks – and is still remembered fifty years later as a turning point in the anti-war movement. So why, when nearly twice that number of protesters have been killed in the month of daily marches and rallies that have rocked this country, have their murders not made the national media? Could it be for the same reason that the killing of four white students at Kent State received far more widespread news coverage than the two Black students killed at Jackson State by police just eleven days later? That reason, which is the same reason that protests have been taking place across the country in the first place, is that six of the seven people killed at the protests have been Black and Brown men. Their lives apparently do not matter much to the national media, which has ignored their stories and focused instead on sporadic riot...

Why would you call the police?

I’ve never had an experience in which calling the police made things better. In every case where I’ve seen them show up, they roll in with bravado, hubris, anger and fear. And in every case I’ve seen and experienced, they make things worse. Been robbed? They don’t care. They’ll make a report, but it’s an annoyance to them, just the necessary paperwork for you to file an insurance claim for what was stolen, if you’re lucky enough to have insurance. Will they go after the robber? Help you deal with the trauma of how unsafe and violated you feel? Ha! Good luck. A car accident? Same thing. Better to just exchange insurance info and take care of it yourselves. If it’s worse than that, medics will arrive. The medics actually help! They calm down the people who’ve just experienced the trauma, they deal with injuries and help address the pain. Police only escalate. They only make things worse. I mean, imagine you’re a young woman who has been raped – would you call the ...